When talking about projectors and which is the best type of projector, words like DLP, LCD, LCoS, SXRD, and DILA are some of the most confusing terms used to describe a projector. Since there is such a variety of projectors on today’s market, finding the best type is not as easy as it may seem. Each of these terms refers to a chip or multiple chips inside of a projector and each of these chips are different than the other ones in very unique ways. So what are the advantages of these displays and are there any disadvantages as well? To answer that, we’ll have to look at each display type individually, starting with a brief summary of each technology.
LCD
You’re probably familiar with the term “LCD” since you might have an LCD computer monitor on your laptop or desktop, an LCD watch, an LCD television, or an LCD on your MP3 player. Similar to all those other electronics, an LCD projector will create an image by passing light through three panels of liquid crystal, one for each of the primary colors, Red, Green, and Blue (RGB). From these 3 color panels, LCD projectors can produce an image of around 16.7 million colors.
DLP
Developed by Texas Instruments, DLP technology consists of an optical semiconductor chip known as a Digital Micromirror Device (DMD). This DMD consists of up to 2 million tiny mirrors that tilt on microscopic hinges to reflect light either towards or away from the lens. Depending on the tilt of the mirrors, they can be used to control the amount of light passing through the lens and allow for deep shades of color and very rich blacks. A single chip projector can produce over 16.7 million colors and a three chip DLP projector can produce over 35 trillion colors.
LCoS
Liquid Crystal on Silicon is relatively new technology and is used by only a few manufacturers and used mostly for home theater and large venue projection. However, despite not being in widespread use, it has some very powerful characteristics. LCoS and its proprietary variations of SXRD and DILA offer some of the sharpest images and highest contrasts of colors of any projector on the market. LCoS is combination of both LCD and DLP technology. Using a highly reflective metal covered by liquid crystals, images are created by projecting light on to the reflective surface where the crystals open and close to reflect the light through the projection lens.
Each display type has its advantages, and most of these advantages are shared between projectors. There is no “bad” or “worst” type of display since they all serve unique purposes. We can examine the advantages and disadvantages of both.
Advantages and Disadvantages of LCD Projectors
After looking around our website, you’ll see that LCD projectors make up the majority of projectors listed. LCD projectors are a popular choice for several reasons, really. LCD projectors can be outfitted for any projection purpose; from portable projectors weighing only a few pounds to large venue projectors for theaters weighing several hundred pounds. LCD panels can be cheaply manufactured as well, and that keeps the cost of LCD projectors very low, and LCD projectors are some of the brightest projectors on the market.
While LCD projectors are very popular, they have some issues that some users can find annoying. The most common problem users have with LCD projectors is small lines that form grids between the individual pixels of an image. This is commonly referred to as the “Screen Door Effect” because it can be like looking at an image through a screen door. While this also creates a sharper image with less blur, and when displaying data or still images, it’s usually not a problem. Usually, this screen door effect is most noticeably seen in video and moving images as well as closely examining an image. The other drawbacks of LCD projectors sometimes are dead pixels. If one of the millions of tiny little pixels dies, it will often project a square that does not change colors on the projection screen. It can be distracting to the projection audience if there are several of these dead pixels spread out over the screen, but it is usually a problem associated with the age of the projector, and most projectors can go for years without a single problem. Historically, there are several other problems with LCD projectors such as “ghosting” also known as “motion blur” where an image will stay on the screen after it had changed and causes a blurry picture momentarily, as well as having poor color saturation and contrasts. However, in recent years, these issues are pretty much non-existent since the technology has evolved and is continuing to evolve. Possibly in the near future, even the screen door effect and dead pixels will be non-existent as well.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Single Chip DLP projectors
Today’s DLP projectors can be used similarly to LCD projectors in nearly every projection environment. Texas Instruments has come a long way to improve DLP technology in recent years and the performance gap between LCD and DLP is very narrow. While they are very similar in capabilities, a single chip DLP projector usually offers two advantages over LCD projectors in today’s market. Current DLP projectors offer higher contrasts and than LCD projectors due to their design, and this usually allows for better viewing of video and images over LCD projectors.
However, while the saturation may be better than LCD, there is still a little bit of a gap between the pixels on the projected image. These gaps are not as noticeable as the screen door effect in LCD projectors, but if you look close enough, you’ll probably be able to see it. The other problem unique to single chip DLP projector is the “Rainbow Effect” when a viewer will sometimes see colors that are out of place on a projected image. Inside of single chip DLP projectors is a color wheel rotating thousands of times a minute to give a projected image color. When the color wheel spins to change colors, some viewers may be able to see the changing of colors. This can be distracting to a viewer and possibly making the projection unwatchable.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Three Chip DLP projectors
Instead of using a color wheel to create color, some large venue and home theater DLP projectors consist of three individual DMD chips and a color filtering prism to create a color image, eliminating the need for the spinning wheel. By producing each of the three colors on separate chips, there are no rainbow artifacts, and some three chip projectors can create up to 35 trillion colors. Most digital films you see today in a cinema are projected using a three chip DLP projector.
However, it does come at quite a cost, with the cheapest three chip projectors costing about $15,000 USD. While that may seem expensive, it may very well be worth it to minimize screen door and eliminate rainbow effects.
Advantages and Disadvantages of LCoS
While having the smallest niche in the projector market, LCoS projectors and its variations SXRD and DILA actually offer the best of both LCD and DLP projectors, with neither of the technical short-comings. There are no screen door or rainbow effects with an LCoS projector. Images are sharp are highly saturated and often tout high contrasts. And while the LCoS projector market is very small at the moment, it will grow expansively in the coming years.
Though, like three chip DLP projectors, LCoS projectors are very expensive. Current LCoS projectors are about as expensive as a three chip DLP projector, coming in at about $15,000 for the cheapest. Still, the picture can justify the expense, because both three chip DLP and LCoS projectors are amazing in areas of Home Cinema.
Conclusion
Depending on your needs in a projector, you should easily be able to decide on what kind of display type would best suit them. While the disadvantages stated can be problematic, screen door and rainbow effects are only a problem for a small percentage of people. The majority of people do not notice either. Still, it is important to note that someone may notice eventually, and if they do, you’ll have an explanation for them. Good Luck and Happy Projecting!